Sunday, October 13, 2013

The God I Don't Believe In #1: The God of Damnation


·      The following sermon is presented as one view point among many in the world of Christian theology.  No expectation of strict agreement with this sermon is necessary for one to use these words as a starting point for conversation.  The pastor submits that he does not have all the answers and is using experience and reason as methods to come to his conclusions. 

In the Christian tradition, hundreds of years of thought have led to certain understandings of who God is for us.  But all those discussions have also led us astray from Biblical upholdings and down a road that is more cultural than Biblical. And along the way, God has been made into something that is all together different.  And so…these are God’s stories…

In the year of our Lord 1555, a lot was going on in Europe.  Only nine years after Martin Luther’s death, and a 35 years since the beginning of the reformation, the Church was in upheavel everywhere.  Catholics were reforming, the Protestant Church had started its great solidication and distancing from the Catholic faith, the divisions that plagued the middle ages were still going on, and  a playright named Dante captured it all in a vision we hear today as the Divine Comedy. For some, in fact for many, it was a brilliant piece of work.  And his eloquence was visioning, especially his depth at creating a model of a nine circle place called hell where souls are sent to burn for all eternity.  If you’d read it you will realize how terrifying and also imaginative it is.  It’s story leads you all the way through the circles until you reach the end.  You’ll need a glass of something stronger than our grape juice to prepare yourself.  It’s an amazing story….BUT THAT”S WHAT IT IS…A STORY.

      Since it’s creation in the 1500s, this vision of hell has been converged into Christian theology.  In 1667, John Milton wrote Paradise Lost and again we were mesmerized by the visions of hell, this time even more molded to Christian identity.  And in the late 19th Century, the Fundamentalist movement tried to circumvent a focus on hell by making one of their five pillars the sacrificial atonement belief about Christ, making him out to be a lawn to be slaughtered by a violent God who was really interested in sending us to fire and brimstone hell.  There’s two more sermons in this series that will address what I just said later.

      But Hell…and Heaven.  The two are intrinsically tied together. When we think about Hell, we see images of fire and of suffering.  But the Jews never saw that.  In fact, what the Jews believed is that when people died, they went to a place called Sheol”, which means the place of muddy waters.  It’s a pretty destitute place, where people kind of milled around.  Nobody really wanted to go there, but they felt that that was it.  They’d all see each other again in this place that wasn’t really all that happy but at least wasn’t burning.  So, Jews never got this idea.  But Jesus spoke of it didn’t he…
      Maybe, but remember, Jesus was a Rabbi.  And if you really look at the message, he didn’t talk about things as different from a Rabbi as you might think.  He wanted people to follow the Sabbath, LIVE out the Torah, etc.  But Cody…he talks about Hell right there in Matthew and Luke.  Well…maybe.
      I think it makes sense to believe that…except when you consider context. And context is everything.  Let’s just start by remembering something I told a few of you a couple of years ago in a sermon…
In Jesus’ time, he seems to talk an awful lot about burning and consuming of things.  Outside of Jerusalem, there’s a garbage dump.  Archeological digs believe it may have been the largest garbage dump in the ancient world, in fact, there is such a large area of it that archeologists are unsure if they are ever going to be able to uncover it all.  But this garbage dump had pretty much everything in it that had rotted and had gone bad.  They didn’t have anything else to do with the stuff.  So what they routinely did was burn up as much stuff as possible, consuming it in brilliant fires that lit up in the night.  The gospels really don’t mention “Eternal damnation” but rather “burning and consuming.”  Heaven and Hell become a shorthand description of what happens when you die, and that description is the NOTHINGNESS… or the eternal life.

            The Weeping and Gnashing of teeth is a little bit harder except focusing on who God is.  And that’s the bigger question of this entire sermon series.  If you imagine that God is a God of damnation, then you can conceptualize that there will be people who end up in hell because they were sent there.  If on the other hand, you just believe that hell exists, then you have to allow yourself to send on toward God and add this awkward understanding of God to what you already believed.  Neither direction of thought seems very exciting.

            John Wesley, the founder of United Methodism, he didn’t focused on hell.  In fact, he focused on Grace, on the idea that God has already forgiven us for our sinfulness, has already restored us to wholeness, and invites us to grow in love to God and to neighbor.  Wesley, along with many of the others, wasn’t focused on hell, he was focused on hope.

Heavenly Alternatives
            When one spends their time worried about avoiding an ill fate, they often do so by establishing an alternative future.  Instead of hell, this is where we could go…and that place is heaven.  You might recognize heaven from Hollywood in movies like Ghost, City of Angels, What Dreams may come, and many many others.  And I admit, Joe last year did get me to read a compelling book about a little boy who medically was dead and started talking about heaven.  And I actually believe Heaven does exist, but I’m not sure we’re headed there.

            The reasons for this are many, and for a moment I want you to conceptualize the common story.  Human beings, born into this world, are given a chance to prove themselves to God.  Some make it, others not so much.  The ones who don’t do so well go to Hell forever.  The good ones, those like you and me (at least I think so) go to heaven to a place of magnificent glory and beautiful people with bagels and cream cheese.  Ok maybe I’m mixing ideas….but that’s really what I think we’re all doing ourselves. 
            Media is a powerful force in the world, and after a while we start thinking that what people have put on the movie screen is actual what the Bible says…and it doesn’t.  In fact, there is VERY little if anything that can be said about heaven.  There are a few stories of angels and singing, of trumpets and magnificent chairs, but mostly what we glean from the Bible is that God is in Heaven and Jesus ascended their after the resurrection.  You may have heard Jesus once or twice refer to this house that has many rooms that has a place prepared for you and me.  But have you also captured those many moments where Jesus says, where I go, you can not be.

The Jewish tradition never believed that people were going anywhere.  That’s why the story of Elijah being taken up to Heaven on a chariot was a big deal.  He didn’t go to Sheol.  And Moses, Abraham, those guys, Jews thought they were there too.  But only Christians think they themselves are going to heaven.  Cody….Jesus said he opened the gates of heaven to us… Or perhaps what the greek translation that we misunderstand is that Jesus brought God to us from Heaven…. Not that we are traveling to Heaven.  In fact, the traveling is supposed to take place by Heaven itself…

           Hear that passage again (Revelation 21:1-4).  The Heaven we are talking about is not us going away. It’s coming here. Who is this God of Damnation.  I don’t see it in this passage.  I see a God of love, returning to be with God’s people in love and hope and to wipe away tears and to bring about the kingdom of God here on earth as it is in Heaven.  And we as Christians are watching for resurrection of all persons.  Sometimes at funerals we bless the memory of the person with these words… May you rest in Peace until you rise in Glory…  That does not mean to Heaven necessarily, but to a new beginning…and that new beginning, it may happen here.
            Do I expect you to believe everything I say about this God.  No. Do I expect this sermon to challenge you.  Absolutely.  But this sermon series is meant to be an extended about who you believe God to be.  For me, certain aspect of God have been misrepresented, starting with God’s focus on eternal damning of most and elected joy of a few.  I’m happy to report that this to me feels like a sad and desperate creation of God in our image rather than that of the Biblical image.  So as we continue throughout these next seven weeks, challenge yourself and begin to articulate the God you believe in, and I’ll keeping working to articulate The God I DON”T believe in.

Amen

No comments:

Post a Comment